I wonder what "The Fun Place" has to do with the "A" and the "I" on the adjacent sign. In some circles, AI means something that isn't necessarily fun, and I'm not talking about intelligence!
A slogan should be in quotes when it takes the form of a nickname. In theory, you might refer to this locale as "the fun place" in a sentence. In the same way that nicknames of people are in quotes, e.g. Joey "The Clown" Lombardo, nicknames of places should perhaps be in quotes as well.
I didn't say that it has to be in quotation marks, but there's a difference between using them for emphasis and using them just to set a slogan apart. Otherwise somebody might think the name is Snow Creek Resort The Fun Place.
No. This sign is clearly not in error. A quote referring to the style or quality of the establishment DOES need quotation marks. As in Kmart, "The Savings Place."
I don't think it matters if the quotes are right or wrong here -- even if they are necessary or not. What's funny is that when I read this sign, I think of someone saying "The Fun Place" out loud with air quotes, and then it sounds really sketchy. ;-)
12 comments:
i've been looking for that place!
Okay, I'm starting to think that things that are obviously slogans shouldn't count anymore.
The words "Snow" and "Creek" make me think this resort is very wet, cold, and slushy.
I wonder what "The Fun Place" has to do with the "A" and the "I" on the adjacent sign. In some circles, AI means something that isn't necessarily fun, and I'm not talking about intelligence!
Jacob, can you direct me to a grammar book where I can find the rule that slogans belong in quotes?
A slogan should be in quotes when it takes the form of a nickname. In theory, you might refer to this locale as "the fun place" in a sentence. In the same way that nicknames of people are in quotes, e.g. Joey "The Clown" Lombardo, nicknames of places should perhaps be in quotes as well.
A slogan is not the same thing as a nickname
I didn't say that it has to be in quotation marks, but there's a difference between using them for emphasis and using them just to set a slogan apart. Otherwise somebody might think the name is Snow Creek Resort The Fun Place.
I guess I'm not arguing that they're incorrect, but the blog is "unnecessary" and they are
No. This sign is clearly not in error. A quote referring to the style or quality of the establishment DOES need quotation marks. As in Kmart, "The Savings Place."
^Link me to a grammar guide with that rule please, anonymous.
I don't think it matters if the quotes are right or wrong here -- even if they are necessary or not. What's funny is that when I read this sign, I think of someone saying "The Fun Place" out loud with air quotes, and then it sounds really sketchy. ;-)
Post a Comment